Arbitration Agreements: What Businesses Need to Know

An arbitration agreement is a contract, or more often a single clause inside one, in which the parties agree to resolve disputes before a private decision-maker instead of a court. For a company, that clause quietly decides where a future fight happens, who decides it, how much evidence you can demand and whether you can appeal. At Cogent Law, we draft and review these clauses for companies in regulated and fast-moving industries, because the wording you accept on day one is the forum you live with on the worst day.
TL;DR
- An arbitration agreement sends covered disputes to a private arbitrator whose decision is usually final, rather than to a judge or jury.
- Under the Federal Arbitration Act, courts generally enforce these agreements as written, so the clause you sign is the clause you get.
- A good clause names the covered disputes, the rules and administrator, the seat (location), the number of arbitrators and the governing law.
- Clauses that are one-sided, buried or too broad can be struck down, which is why mutuality and plain drafting matter, especially with employees and consumers.
- Review the clause before the dispute, not after: once a claim exists, your options narrow quickly.
Table of Contents
- What an arbitration agreement is
- What the clause controls
- How arbitration differs from court
- How courts enforce arbitration agreements
- Can you still sue after signing?
- What to include when drafting or reviewing a clause
- Why regulated-industry companies should look closely
- How Cogent Law helps
- FAQ
- Sources
What an arbitration agreement is
An arbitration agreement is typically a clause in a broader contract in which the parties agree to settle disputes out of court. The Harvard Program on Negotiation describes businesses using them to cut dispute-resolution costs and improve efficiency. You will see the same idea called an arbitration clause when it sits inside a larger agreement, and a standalone arbitration agreement when it is a separate document.
These provisions are everywhere. The Congressional Research Service notes they appear in business-to-business, employment, collective bargaining and consumer contracts, including terms of service for credit cards, cell phones, online retailers, social media platforms and ridesharing apps. If your company has a customer agreement, a vendor contract, a SaaS order form, an investor side letter or an employment offer, it probably either contains one or could.
Most agreements give each side two rights, according to the Federal Register. Either party can file a claim in arbitration and obtain a decision. And either party can use the agreement to require that a dispute filed in court go to arbitration instead. That second right matters in practice: a motion to compel arbitration is often the first move a defendant makes.
Not every subject can be arbitrated. Professor Susan Franck notes in the Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Economics and Finance that arbitrability, meaning whether a subject can be resolved by arbitration, remains a recurring question, with family law and criminal matters generally outside it. For commercial disputes between companies, that rarely limits you.
What the clause controls
The clause is where you design the dispute process. The CRS explains that an arbitration agreement can specify which disputes are covered, how arbitrators are selected, where and in what format the hearing happens, and the procedural rules. Each of those is a lever with business consequences.

Scope. “Any dispute arising out of or relating to this agreement” reaches much further than “disputes about payment under this agreement.” Broad language can pull in tort and statutory claims connected to the relationship. Decide on purpose whether you want that.
Administrator and rules. Many agreements name an arbitration administrator, which helps select arbitrators and supplies procedural rules, as the Federal Register explains. The ABA’s GPSolo magazine notes that established institutional frameworks, including the American Arbitration Association, JAMS and the ICC, allow a clause to be short: a single sentence sending disputes to arbitration under that body’s rules.
Seat and language. The seat is the legal home of the arbitration. It determines which courts supervise the process and which procedural law applies at the edges. Pick it deliberately, especially in cross-border deals.
Arbitrators. The same ABA article suggests a single arbitrator for modest claims and often a three-member panel for larger ones. A panel costs more and takes longer to schedule, but it gives each side a voice in the selection.
How arbitration differs from court
The differences are the reason companies choose arbitration, so they should be weighed against your own disputes.
| Feature | Typical arbitration | Typical court case |
|---|---|---|
| Formality | Less formal; some court procedure and evidence rules may not apply | Full rules of procedure and evidence |
| Discovery | Often more limited | Broader |
| Privacy | Hearings usually private | Generally public record |
| Decision-maker | Chosen by the parties, who may select specialized experience | Assigned judge, often a jury |
| Review | Awards reviewable only on narrow statutory grounds | Ordinary appeal rights |
The table draws on the CRS summary. The Federal Register record adds that most arbitration provides limited or streamlined discovery and that appeal rights are very narrow.
For a growth company, the practical upside is speed, confidentiality and expertise. The Harvard Program on Negotiation points out that arbitration is relatively inexpensive, brief and confidential compared with litigation, and that arbitrators can craft more creative remedies than a civil court, such as ordering an employee reinstated rather than only awarding money. Confidentiality is valuable when a dispute involves a licensing issue, a banking partner or investor relations you would rather not see in a public docket.
Because review is so narrow, the finality cuts both ways. The CRS says awards are usually reviewable only on grounds focused on arbitrator misconduct rather than legal or factual error. That makes the choice of arbitrator, rules and panel size the real safeguard, and it is why those terms deserve attention at signing.
How courts enforce arbitration agreements
The governing statute is the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), enacted in 1925. Its core provision, 9 U.S.C. § 2, makes a written arbitration provision in a contract involving commerce valid, irrevocable and enforceable, except on grounds that exist at law or in equity to revoke any contract. In plain terms, courts treat an arbitration clause like any other contract term and enforce it, and ordinary defenses such as fraud, duress or unconscionability remain available. The CRS describes this as placing arbitration agreements on the same footing as other contracts.
Three consequences matter for operators.
State laws have limited room to disfavor arbitration. The CRS notes that the FAA preempts state laws that disfavor arbitration or interfere with its fundamental attributes. The Ninth Circuit applied that reasoning to California’s Assembly Bill 51, which barred mandatory arbitration as a condition of employment, and held it preempted, as the ABA GPSolo article describes.
Class waivers are generally enforceable. The Supreme Court has interpreted the FAA to make class action waivers in arbitration agreements generally enforceable, and parties cannot be compelled to arbitrate on a classwide basis unless the agreement provides for it. In Cordero v. Coinbase (N.D. Cal., August 5, 2025), the court granted a motion to compel arbitration in a class action over cryptocurrency transaction fees, holding that a state-law attack on the class waiver was preempted under AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion, as the opinion explains.
Who decides arbitrability can be written into the clause. In that same case, a delegation clause, which sends questions about whether a dispute is arbitrable to the arbitrator, meant those questions belonged before the arbitrator and not the court. If you want threshold fights resolved in one forum, say so expressly.
Courts do still scrutinize clauses. The Ninth Circuit in Cocom v. ABM Aviation (June 23, 2026) held that most challenged provisions of a master arbitration agreement were not substantively unconscionable and that remaining problem provisions, including a waiver of representative PAGA actions and a bar on public injunctive relief, could be severed, so the agreement survived. In Stoker v. Blue Origin, by contrast, the court found the agreement overbroad, unconscionable and not severable. The lesson is drafting discipline: a clause with several aggressive terms risks losing the whole benefit it was meant to deliver.
Can you still sue after signing?
Often the answer is only on narrow terms. If your claim falls within the clause, a court will typically send it to arbitration on the other side’s motion. Courts decline to do so when a generally applicable contract defense applies, when the dispute falls outside the clause’s scope, or when the clause carves it out.
The ABA GPSolo author David Donald says the most common grounds for rescinding an arbitration clause are findings of procedural unfairness: whether the weaker party understood it was giving up a court proceeding, and whether the private forum is fair in substance. A clause that binds one party while leaving the other free to sue invites invalidation, especially in consumer contexts.
In Flores v. New York Football Giants, the Second Circuit affirmed the denial of a motion to compel arbitration of a putative class action by NFL coaches, showing that outcomes depend on the specific agreement and claims, as reflected in the filed appendix. That is the reason to have counsel read the exact clause before you rely on it or sign it.
What to include when drafting or reviewing a clause
The ABA’s Business Law Today sets out the core of an effective clause: define the disputes covered, commit the parties to arbitrate, choose institutional or ad hoc rules and an appointing authority, and specify the seat and language. Beyond that, businesses may address governing law, arbitrator number, selection and qualifications, provisional relief and any appeal process.
Use this as a working checklist:
- Scope. Which claims are in? Contract only, or related statutory and tort claims too?
- Rules and administrator. Name them precisely. An ambiguous reference can spawn a fight before the merits begin.
- Seat, language and format. Decide whether hearings are in person or remote.
- Arbitrators. Choose the number, required qualifications (for example, experience in payments regulation or life sciences) and the method of selection.
- Governing law. Keep it consistent with your other contract terms and with the seat.
- Interim relief. Preserve the ability to seek an injunction in court to protect IP or confidential information while the arbitration proceeds.
- Fallbacks. Mia Levi cautions in the same ABA publication that purely ad hoc arbitration can stall on appointment or fee disputes because no neutral institution monitors billing or scheduling, and suggests non-administered rules with fallback provisions as a safety net.
- Carve-outs. Consider excluding small claims, injunctions or collective actions where appropriate.
Extra care for employment and consumer contracts
When the counterparty is an employee or a consumer, the standard is higher. The ABA GPSolo article states the clause should be clear and conspicuous, include a jury-trial waiver, use plain language, be mutual, offer a convenient location such as remote hearings, and carve out small claims, injunctions or collective actions. A mandatory clause covering a statutory claim must provide the relief a court would make available under that statute. If you use one standard arbitration clause across customer terms, offer letters and vendor contracts, each audience needs its own version.
Why regulated-industry companies should look closely
Companies in fintech, crypto, cannabis, life sciences and energy sign arbitration clauses in unusual places: bank-partner agreements, licensing sponsors, custody and processor contracts, token purchase terms, investor documents and joint ventures. These relationships often involve a regulator who is not a party to the clause and a counterparty with more leverage than you.
For those reasons, a few questions are worth asking each time:
- Does the clause conflict with a regulatory obligation, such as record access or reporting duties? Confidentiality in arbitration does not displace what a regulator may require.
- Does it let you seek emergency court relief if a banking partner or platform cuts off access?
- Does the same clause appear in your consumer terms, where a class waiver and mutuality requirements become central?
- Will the arbitrators understand the industry? Specialized qualifications in the clause are usually easier to negotiate before the relationship starts.
These are exactly the points an attorney with transactional and dispute experience in your sector can settle in an afternoon of review, versus months of motion practice later.
How Cogent Law helps
Our attorneys bring large-firm and in-house experience to companies in regulated and emerging industries, and our practice spans corporate and M&A, litigation and dispute resolution, FinTech, blockchain and cryptocurrency, cannabis and hemp, life sciences, banking and financial services and more. For arbitration clauses, that means reviewing the agreement against your business, your regulators and your counterparties, and drafting terms you can live with if a dispute arrives. We offer upfront budgets and estimates, along with fixed-fee and hybrid arrangements, so you know what a review or drafting project will cost before it starts.

If a contract with an arbitration clause is on your desk, or you are building the dispute provisions for your own customer and vendor terms, see our corporate law practice or the full list of practice areas, and bring us the document.
FAQ
What is the purpose of an arbitration agreement?
It gives the parties a single, predictable forum for disputes, so time and money go to resolving the dispute and not to arguing about where it belongs. Susan Franck describes this reduction in dispute-resolution risk as a main benefit. Businesses also use it for confidentiality, speed and access to specialized decision-makers.
Is an arbitration clause the same as an arbitration agreement?
Functionally, yes. A clause is an arbitration agreement written as one provision inside a larger contract, which is the most common form. A standalone agreement is a separate document, used for example when parties agree to arbitrate after a dispute has already arisen.
Is an arbitration decision final?
Usually, yes. Awards under the FAA are generally reviewable only on narrow statutory grounds that focus on arbitrator misconduct, not on legal or factual mistakes. That is why choosing the rules, administrator and arbitrators carefully at drafting matters so much.
Are class action waivers in arbitration agreements enforceable?
Generally yes. The Supreme Court has read the FAA to make them enforceable even where individual claims are small, as the CRS summary explains. Enforceability still depends on the specific agreement and on defenses such as unconscionability, so the wording matters.
Sources
- What is an Arbitration Agreement? Harvard Program on Negotiation
- The Federal Arbitration Act and Class Action Waivers, Congressional Research Service
- Arbitration Agreements, Federal Register, July 19, 2017
- The Fundamentals of Arbitration, Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Economics and Finance
- 9 U.S.C. § 2: Validity, irrevocability, and enforcement of agreements to arbitrate
- Designing Effective Arbitration Clauses, ABA GPSolo
- Let the Pen Be Your Sword: Crafting Powerful ADR Contractual Provisions, ABA Business Law Today
- Cordero v. Coinbase, Inc. (N.D. Cal. 2025)
- Cocom v. ABM Aviation, Inc., No. 25-3246 (9th Cir. 2026)
- Stoker v. Blue Origin LLC (2026)
- Flores v. New York Football Giants, Inc., appendix (2d Cir. 2025)
