Gain Recognition Agreements Under Section 367(a): A Guide

A gain recognition agreement (GRA) is a promise you make to the IRS so that a U.S. company can move foreign stock into a foreign corporation without paying tax on the built-in gain right away. The promise has teeth: if the foreign corporation sells the stock, or another triggering event happens, during the next five full tax years, you owe the deferred tax plus interest. Getting a GRA right is a tax, corporate and cross-border task at once, which is why our tax and corporate attorneys treat it as part of the deal structure and not as a form to complete after closing.
TL;DR
- A GRA lets a U.S. transferor avoid immediate gain under section 367(a)(1) on an outbound transfer of foreign stock or securities, if it agrees to recognize that gain on certain later events.
- You need one when you own 5% or more of the foreign transferee, by vote or value, right after the transfer. Below 5% on both measures, no GRA is required.
- The GRA must be filed with your timely filed return for the year of the transfer, together with Form 8838. A late or incomplete filing can cost you the nonrecognition treatment.
- The term runs through the fifth full tax year after the transfer year, with an annual certification each year.
- If the failure to file was not willful, the regulations offer relief, but it is a procedure you want to avoid needing.
Table of Contents
- What a gain recognition agreement is, and why it exists
- When your company needs one
- How to file a gain recognition agreement
- Annual certification and ongoing duties
- How long the agreement lasts and what triggers gain
- What happens when gain is triggered
- Relief for a missed or deficient filing
- Where Cogent Law fits
- FAQ
- Sources
What a gain recognition agreement is, and why it exists
Section 367(a) is the anti-abuse rule behind outbound transfers. Normally you can contribute property to a corporation in a tax-free exchange. When the receiving corporation is foreign, the general rule flips: the transfer is taxable, because the appreciation could otherwise leave the U.S. tax net for good.
The regulations carve out an exception for transfers of foreign stock or securities. Under 26 CFR 1.367(a)-3, a transfer of this kind to a foreign corporation is not hit by section 367(a)(1) if the transferor owns less than 5% of both the total voting power and the total value of the transferee immediately after the transfer, or if the transferor enters into a five-year GRA under section 1.367(a)-8.
The California Franchise Tax Board’s water’s-edge manual describes the same idea in plain terms: a GRA is a binding agreement in which the U.S. shareholder agrees to recognize gain, and entering into one keeps the transfer out of section 367(a)(1). The rule dates to the 1998 regulations (T.D. 8770, effective July 20, 1998), which set the basic bargain still in force: nonrecognition now, gain plus interest later if the foreign corporation disposes of the stock in a taxable transaction during the term.
When your company needs one
The 5% test decides it. Look at your ownership of the foreign transferee immediately after the transfer, measured two ways: voting power and value. If you hold less than 5% on both, the exception applies without any agreement. If you hold 5% or more on either measure, the exception is available only through a GRA.
This comes up more often than founders expect:
- A U.S. parent contributes the shares of one foreign subsidiary to another foreign subsidiary as part of an internal reorganization.
- A U.S. company exchanges its stake in a foreign operating company for shares of a foreign acquirer in a cross-border merger.
- A U.S. founder holding foreign company shares personally contributes them to a new foreign holding company.
In each case the question is the same: is this a transfer of foreign stock or securities by a U.S. person to a foreign corporation, and do you keep 5% or more? If so, the GRA decides whether you pay tax on the gain this year or carry a contingent liability for five more.
A worked example
This is an illustration with round numbers, not a real transaction. A U.S. company holds all the shares of a foreign operating company. Its tax basis is $2 million and the fair market value is $10 million, so the built-in gain is $8 million. It contributes those shares to a foreign holding company in exchange for 100% of the holding company’s stock.
Without a GRA, the company would recognize the $8 million gain on the contribution. With a timely, complete GRA, it recognizes nothing now. If the holding company then sells the operating company’s shares in a taxable sale in year three, the U.S. company must include the $8 million gain in income, amend the return for the transfer year, and pay interest from that return’s original due date. Under the regulations, a partial disposition triggers a proportionate share: if the foreign corporation sells half the transferred stock by fair market value, half the gain is recognized. The regulation’s text sets out that proportionate rule.

That is the real cost-benefit: deferral is valuable, but only if the business plan for the next five-plus years does not include selling or restructuring away the transferred stock.
How to file a gain recognition agreement
Filing is mechanical but unforgiving. Section 1.367(a)-8(d)(1) requires the initial GRA and every required GRA document to be included with the transferor’s timely filed return for the year of the transfer, with each document completed in all material respects. Timely filing is a condition of using the exceptions in section 1.367(a)-3 at all, per the same regulation.
- Confirm the transfer fits. Identify what is transferred, who the transferor is, and your post-transfer ownership by vote and value. Mistakes here cascade into the rest of the filing.
- Value the stock and compute the gain. The GRA records the gain realized but not recognized. Get the basis and fair market value work done before the return is due, since this is the number you commit to.
- Prepare the GRA and its supporting documents. These go in with the return. A missing or materially incomplete document is treated as an untimely filing.
- File Form 8838. The IRS says Form 8838 is the consent used for GRAs under sections 367(a) and 367(e)(2). It extends the period for assessing tax through the close of the eighth full taxable year after the transfer year.
- Check your related international reporting. A GRA does not stand alone. An IRS memorandum, AM 2017-005, shows how GRA filing interacts with section 6038B reporting for the same transfer.
- Calendar the annual certifications for the following five years (covered below).
On the entity side, a foreign corporation doing business in a U.S. state also has its own state filings, which run on a separate calendar from your federal return. Foreign corporation filing due dates are worth tracking alongside the tax deadlines so that neither slips during a busy closing.
The usual failure point is timing. Deals close late in the year, the return extension gets filed, and nobody notices that the GRA has to go with the return, not after it. Build the GRA into the closing checklist, with the tax team’s sign-off on the gain computation before the signing, not after.
Annual certification and ongoing duties
Filing the initial GRA is not the end. Under paragraph (g) of the regulation, you attach an annual certification to your timely filed return for each of the five full taxable years after the transfer year. It must state:
- whether a gain recognition event occurred, with the amounts of gain subject to the GRA and recognized under it;
- any event that terminated or reduced the gain subject to the GRA; and
- any disposition of the transferred corporation’s assets outside the ordinary course of business.
An unsigned copy filed with the return satisfies the signature requirement if you keep the signed original under the recordkeeping rules. In practice the certification is only as good as your internal reporting: the person who signs it needs to know what the foreign subsidiary did with its assets all year, which is information finance teams in a fast-growing company do not always pass along.
How long the agreement lasts and what triggers gain
The GRA term runs from the date of the initial transfer through the close of the fifth full taxable year following the transfer year, and never less than 60 months, per section 1.367(a)-8©(1)(i). A transfer in March of year one therefore carries the agreement to the end of year six.
Paragraph (j) of the same section lists ten triggering events. In plain terms:
| Trigger | What it means |
|---|---|
| Disposition of the transferred stock or securities | A full or partial sale or other disposition |
| Disposition of substantially all of the transferred corporation’s assets | Ordinary-course sales and certain reorganization and liquidation exchanges are disregarded |
| Disposition of certain partnership interests | Applies where the structure runs through a partnership |
| Disposition of the transferee’s stock | Includes a deemed disposition when an individual loses U.S. citizenship or lawful permanent resident status |
| Deconsolidation | A member leaves a consolidated group |
| Joining a consolidated group | The transferor becomes a member of one |
| Death or termination | Death of an individual transferor, or a trust or estate ceasing to exist |
| Material failure to comply | Not following the regulation or the GRA’s own terms |
| Indirect dispositions | In indirect stock transfers and certain triangular asset reorganizations |
| Events named in a new GRA | For agreements entered under paragraph (k)(14) |
The eCFR text of the regulation is the authority for the list. Two items catch growth companies most often: a later sale or merger of the foreign group, and a restructuring that moves the transferor into or out of a consolidated group.
Reorganizations that do not end the agreement
Not every later transaction triggers gain. Paragraph (k) provides 14 exceptions for nonrecognition transactions in which, immediately afterward, the U.S. transferor keeps a direct or indirect interest in the transferred stock, securities or assets and enters into a new GRA for the initial transfer. That makes it possible to reorganize the foreign group during the term, as long as the replacement agreement is filed correctly. Plan any post-closing restructuring against the GRA before you begin it.
What happens when gain is triggered
If a triggering event occurs, you include in income the gain you realized but did not recognize on the initial transfer, in proportion for a partial disposition. The reporting steps in section 1.367(a)-8© are:
- File an amended return for the year of the initial transfer within 90 days of the event, unless the paragraph ©(2)(vi) election applies, in which case you report the gain on the return for the year of the event.
- Pay interest at the section 6621 rates from the original return’s prescribed filing date until payment, with a schedule titled “Calculation of Section 367 Tax and Interest.”
- Use losses and credits as you normally would: the regulation sets no special limits on offsetting the gain with net operating losses, capital losses or credits.
A material failure to comply under paragraph (j)(8) also extends the assessment period for the year in which the gain is reported, until the close of the third full taxable year ending after you give the required information to the IRS Large Business and International division’s Director of Field Operations, Cross Border Activities.
The 90-day clock is short. If a sale of the foreign subsidiary is on the horizon, the tax computation should be part of the deal model from the start, so that the amended return is largely drafted when the closing occurs.
Relief for a missed or deficient filing
The regulations recognize that filings sometimes fail. Under paragraph (p), described in the Federal Register’s 2014 rule on failures to file GRAs, relief is available if the failure to file the initial GRA, or a paragraph (j)(8) failure to comply, was not willful. Willful includes gross negligence, reckless disregard and willful neglect, judged on all the facts and circumstances.
To use it, you promptly file an amended return with the required information, a written explanation, and a Form 8838 that extends the assessment period to the later of the eighth full taxable year after the transfer or the third full taxable year ending after the information reaches the Director. The IRS’s relief page for gain recognition agreements confirms the not-willful standard and the link to section 6038B reporting, where penalties can still apply absent reasonable cause. Final regulations effective March 22, 2016 (Federal Register, IRS-2013-0013) modified these relief procedures.
The IRS published a notice on October 9, 2026 inviting comments on the Form 8838 information collection and stating no change to the existing collection. The substantive GRA rules above are the ones to plan around, but check the current form instructions when you file.
Where Cogent Law fits
A GRA sits where tax, corporate structuring and deal timing meet, and it is easiest to get right when it is designed with the transaction. Cogent Law advises companies in fintech, blockchain, life sciences, energy and other regulated industries, and our attorneys bring large-firm and in-house experience to cross-border tax and M&A work. We offer upfront budgets and estimates, with fixed-fee and hybrid arrangements available, so you know the cost of structuring and filing before the closing calendar gets tight.

If you are planning an outbound transfer, a foreign reorganization or a cross-border acquisition, see our practice areas and bring us in before the terms are final.
FAQ
Do I need a GRA if I own less than 5% of the foreign company?
No. If you own less than 5% of both the total voting power and the total value of the transferee right after the transfer, the exception in section 1.367(a)-3 applies without a GRA. Ownership at 5% or more on either measure requires the agreement to keep the nonrecognition treatment.
How long does a gain recognition agreement last?
It runs from the date of the transfer through the close of the fifth full taxable year after the transfer year, and not less than 60 months. You file an annual certification with your return for each of those five years.
What is Form 8838 for?
Form 8838 is the consent to extend the time to assess tax that accompanies a GRA under sections 367(a) and 367(e)(2). It keeps the IRS’s assessment window open through the close of the eighth full taxable year after the transfer year.
What if we miss the GRA filing deadline?
Relief may be available if the failure was not willful. You file an amended return with the required information, a written explanation and a new Form 8838, and the IRS decides on the facts. Section 6038B penalties can still apply without reasonable cause, so raise it with your tax counsel as soon as you find the gap.
Sources
- 26 CFR 1.367(a)-3 (eCFR)
- 26 CFR 1.367(a)-8 (eCFR)
- 26 CFR 1.367(a)-8 (Cornell LII)
- California FTB Water’s Edge Manual, Chapter 17
- T.D. 8770 (IRS)
- About Form 8838 (IRS)
- IRS Memorandum AM 2017-005
- Federal Register, Failure to File Gain Recognition Agreements (2014)
- IRS, Relief for gain recognition agreements
- Federal Register, Indirect Stock Transfers final regulations (2016)
- Federal Register, Form 8838 comment request (2026)
- Foreign corporation filing due dates
