Skip to main content
    U.S. Litigation, Enforcement & Regulatory RiskTrending This Month

    10th Circuit Vacates NCAA Eligibility Rule Injunction

    November 17, 2026U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, Wisne v. NCAA, No. 26-1309, opinion (Nov. 6, 2026), official copy via GovInfoFederal3 min read

    On November 6, 2026, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a lower-court decision that would have granted thousands of college athletes a fifth year of eligibility, and it vacated the nationwide injunction behind it. The three-judge panel held that the players' proposed labor market, all of "Division I athletics in the United States," wasn't supported by the evidence.

    So did the NCAA actually win? For now, yes. But this is a ruling on a preliminary injunction, not a final judgment on the players' antitrust claim, and the lawsuit isn't over.

    What the Wisne Lawsuit Challenges

    The case is Wisne v. NCAA, No. 26-1309. Brock Wisne, a University of Northern Colorado basketball player, filed the class action in federal court in Colorado on July 8, 2026, on behalf of players who graduated high school in 2022. They entered college that fall, played four straight seasons and finished their fourth in 2025-26.

    The players argue under Section 1 of the Sherman Act that refusing to extend the new rule to them is an unlawful restraint of trade in the labor market for Division I athletes. All but one say they earned name, image and likeness (NIL) money last season.

    In July, U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney found they were likely to succeed and ordered a fifth season. The association appealed, and on August 21 a divided panel paused that order while the appeal moved forward on an expedited track. The association's chief legal officer, Scott Bearby, said the stay let Division I return to the status quo. Players who had rejoined their teams were ineligible again almost overnight.

    The Five-Year Eligibility Rule and the Class of 2022

    Until June 2026, Division I players had four seasons of competition within a five-year period. On June 23, the association announced an age-based eligibility model that generally allows up to five seasons in five years.

    The catch was timing. The new model applies to prospects first enrolling full time in fall 2027 or later, and anyone who used a final season under the old rules in 2025-26 gets no extra year. That line is exactly what the Class of 2022 athletes challenged.

    The court also acknowledged a bigger shift in college sports. NIL payments and revenue sharing have made recruiting look more like a traditional job market, and that has fueled a wave of Sherman Act suits over who gets to play.

    Why the Court Rejected the Players' Market Definition

    Judges McHugh, Kelly and Moritz reviewed the market definition for clear error. Writing for the panel, Judge Carolyn McHugh said the court was "not convinced" the market could be defined as all Division I athletics in the United States.

    Why? The real employers are individual programs, not the association as a whole, and players don't see every Division I school as a substitute. A football player hunting for a roster spot, for instance, wouldn't view the 101 Division I schools without a football program as real alternatives. The court also rejected a fallback "submarket" theory because the plaintiffs hadn't defined one or backed it with data.

    What the judges left alone matters, too. They didn't reach anticompetitive effects, procompetitive justifications or less restrictive alternatives, and they didn't decide whether antitrust law reaches these rules at all.

    How Other Courts Have Handled Similar Challenges

    This court ruling fits a pattern. The panel pointed to decisions from the Third, Fourth and Seventh Circuits (Elad, Robinson and Fourqurean) that reversed or vacated orders favoring players, and it cited the Ninth's Blythe decision on market definition.

    Federal courts aren't the whole story, though. The August stay didn't touch separate rulings from state courts across the country, and similar suits are still pending. A player's status can depend on where, and in which court, a case was filed.

    What the Ruling Means for Student-Athletes, Schools and NIL Deals

    A single season can carry real money. Nearly all of the plaintiffs say another year would mean more NIL income, and schools, collectives, sponsors and agents build deals around playing status. When a court order appears and then disappears mid-season, those deals can land in limbo.

    The decision also shows how much evidence matters. The court suggested that properly defined markets would likely show men's basketball players face different conditions than women's volleyball players. Our read: future challengers will build sport-specific markets backed by economic data from day one. None of that guarantees the NCAA will win the case on the merits, but it holds the upper hand for now.

    Practical Considerations for NCAA Eligibility and the Wisne Appeal

    Every situation is different, but schools, players and businesses often consider steps like these:

    • Reviewing how NIL and sponsorship agreements handle a change in playing status, including a court order that's stayed or reversed mid-season.
    • Confirming which rules and transition provisions apply to a given player, since the association's announcement treats different groups differently.
    • Watching the related cases, because courts are closely scrutinizing how markets are defined and supported.
    • Tracking further proceedings in Wisne, since this ruling addresses only the preliminary stage.

    Counsel can help assess how the rules and pending litigation may apply to a specific player, school or business.

    Cogent Law Perspective on the NCAA Eligibility Ruling

    Clients often ask what an early ruling like this means for the underlying dispute. Here, the panel found the plaintiffs hadn't shown a likelihood of success on their proposed market, and it did so before any trial. The case isn't over, but these players now face a steeper climb. Our Sports Law practice works with athletes, sports organizations and businesses on contracts, NIL agreements and disputes, and our Litigation & Dispute Resolution team handles contested matters.

    Key Takeaways on the Tenth Circuit's NCAA Eligibility Decision

    • On November 6, 2026, the court reversed the order and vacated the nationwide relief.
    • The panel rejected a market of all Division I athletics as too broad and unsupported.
    • The ruling doesn't resolve the merits of the plaintiffs' Sherman Act claim.
    • The association's choice not to apply its new rule retroactively is no longer blocked.
    • The decision lines up with recent rulings from three other federal appeals courts.

    Contact Us Now

    Tracy L. Schimelfenig of Cogent Law's Sports Law practice advises clients across the corporate, nonprofit and sports industries. To discuss how this ruling may affect your organization, contact Cogent Law or call 202-644-8880.

    Related Practice Areas

    Talk to Cogent Law

    Have questions about how this update may affect your business?

    To discuss how this ruling may affect your organization, contact Cogent Law or call 202-644-8880.

    Legal Disclaimer

    This article provides general information only. It is not legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.

    Speak With Counsel

    Relevant Cogent Law attorneys

    Businesses following this development may want to speak with counsel familiar with this area.